Hello Marc,
Do you have 3 different separate email accounts setup under "Tools>Manage Email Accounts"?
If not, that would be the cause of your problem.
There is currently no way within OnTime to configure one email
address to accept and automatically sort items into different item
types.
You need to have a different mail account for defects, one for features, and of course one for incidents. It sounds as if you have only one account setup, and it seems like that account is working correctly. You'll notice in the Email Account settings that you must specify which item type to convert an email into- and in your case I'd bet you have it set to 'Incident'.
Even though an incident is moved to another item type manually, when a reply email gets sent to that mail account OnTime is configured to turn it into an Incident, even if the numbers in the brackets match an existing ID in another item type.
Let me know if you need further clarification or if you have any other questions.
Thank you,
Tom Harder
Axosoft Support
support@axosoft.com1.800.653.0024 option 3--'Fear the Bug' Podcast--